| 1986 Samuel Simpson IV | 1999 Andrea Kimberly King |
| 1987 William Lloyd Clark | 2000 Owen Edwards Barrow |
| 1988 Matthew Paul Brown | 2001 Kaylor Elizabeth Russell |
| 1989 Jason Leon Steele | 2002 Catherine McKnitt Alexander |
| 1990 Shari Noelle Jordan | 2003 Meagan Elizabeth Griffin |
| 1991 Josie B. Brown | 2004 John Borden Ward |
| 1994 Todd Webb Gaylord | 2005 Carson Powell Padgett |
| 1995 Shannon Taylor MacFarlane | 2006 Elizabeth Esther Sibrack |
| 1996 Elizabeth MacDonald Dempsey | 2007 William Mardre Bobbitt |
| 1996 James Prescott Little | 2008 Morgan Parker Abbott |
| 1997 David Hayes Permar | 2009 William Heathcote |
| 1998 Jessica Ivy Peacock | |
